Sigma 17-40mm F1.8 vs Tamron 17-70mm F2.8 — Low Light vs Versatility?
Verdict: IT DEPENDS
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Sigma 17-40mm F1.8 DC Art gives you more light, an internal zoom and an aperture ring. The Tamron 17-70mm F2.8 Di III-A VC RXD gives you almost twice the reach plus optical stabilization, for the same weight on your camera. Which one is right depends less on the lenses and more on your camera body. If it has no in-body stabilization, the Tamron has a big head start.
Spec comparison
Figures are from Sigma and Tamron for the Sony E-mount versions.
| Feature | Sigma 17-40mm F1.8 DC Art | Tamron 17-70mm F2.8 Di III-A VC RXD |
|---|---|---|
| Focal range (full-frame equivalent) | 17-40mm (25.5-60mm) | 17-70mm (25.5-105mm) |
| Aperture | Constant f/1.8 | Constant f/2.8 |
| Optical stabilization | No | Yes (Tamron VC) |
| Focus motor | HLA linear motor | RXD stepping motor |
| Minimum focus distance | 28 cm | 19 cm (wide) / 39 cm (tele) |
| Zoom design | Internal | Extending |
| Weight | 525 g | 525 g |
| Size (diameter × length) | 72.9 × 117.9 mm | 74.6 × 119.3 mm (at 17mm) |
| Filter thread | 67mm | 67mm |
| Aperture ring | Yes, with click and lock switches | No |
| Switches and buttons | AF/MF switch, two AFL buttons | None on the Sony version |
| Weather resistance | Dust- and splash-resistant | Moisture-resistant seals |
| Other mounts | L-Mount, Fujifilm X, Canon RF | Fujifilm X, Nikon Z, Canon RF |
| Launch price (US) | $919 (2025) | $799 (2021) |
The Tamron has been on sale for years and often sells below its launch price, so check the current price on both.
Same weight, very different jobs
On paper, these two look like rivals. They weigh exactly the same on Sony E, they take the same 67mm filters, and they’re within a couple of millimetres of each other in length at the wide end. But they spend that 525 g in completely different ways.
Sigma spends it on aperture. f/1.8 is about 1⅓ stops brighter than f/2.8, or roughly 2.4 times the light. That buys you a cleaner, lower-ISO image in a dim room and a much shallower depth of field.
Tamron spends it on range and stabilization. It reaches 70mm (105mm equivalent), which covers everything from a wide street scene to a tight portrait or a speaker on a stage. It also has built-in vibration compensation (VC), so you can use slower shutter speeds handheld and get steadier handheld video.
So the honest framing is this: the Sigma is a fast “two primes in one” lens, while the Tamron is a one-lens-for-the-whole-trip zoom.
Stabilization vs aperture: check your camera first
This is the part most comparisons skip, and it’s the deciding factor for a lot of Sony shooters.
If your camera has no in-body stabilization (for example the a6100, a6400 or ZV-E10), the Sigma is completely unstabilized. For stills that’s manageable, because the extra light lets you keep shutter speeds up. For handheld video, though, every footstep shows. The Tamron’s VC fixes much of that, and Lenstip rated it as effective in its review.
If your camera does have IBIS (such as the a6600, a6700 or FX30), the gap shrinks a lot. The body already steadies the Sigma, so the Tamron’s advantage becomes one of degree rather than kind.
It’s also worth noting that stabilization only helps with your shake. If your subject moves, as at a wedding reception or a kids’ party, you still need a fast shutter speed to freeze them. That’s where f/1.8 helps and VC doesn’t. I go deeper into this trade in my guide to Sony a6100 lenses for travel video, which is written around a body without IBIS.
Image quality
Sigma 17-40mm: Lenstip measured excellent centre sharpness across the range, very good edges and slight focus breathing, but flagged strong vignetting and uncorrected distortion in raw files at both ends of the zoom. PetaPixel found corners soft at f/1.8 that improve by f/4, plus visible longitudinal chromatic aberration. With lens profiles applied in camera or in your raw editor, most of that is cleaned up automatically.
Tamron 17-70mm: Lenstip found very good centre sharpness and reasonable edges, with fast, silent AF and effective stabilization. Its main complaints were high vignetting at both ends and so-so performance against bright light (flare and ghosting). Photography Blog noted obvious barrel distortion at 17mm and pincushion at 70mm, which in-camera corrections also handle.
So neither lens is optically “pure”. Both rely on profiles to some extent. Where they really differ is the look. At 40mm f/1.8, the Sigma separates a subject from the background in a way the Tamron can’t match at 40mm f/2.8. At 70mm f/2.8, though, the Tamron gets surprisingly close for portraits, because the longer focal length compresses and blurs the background too. If portraits are your main reason to buy, don’t write the Tamron off.
Autofocus and video
Both lenses focus quietly. Reviewers describe the Tamron’s RXD stepping motor as almost silent and fast, and Sigma’s HLA linear motor is described by Lenstip as quiet, fast and accurate. For everyday stills and vlogging, I wouldn’t choose between these two on AF alone.
The video differences are in the design:
- Internal vs extending zoom. The Sigma keeps the same length through its range, which keeps a gimbal balanced. The Tamron extends as you zoom toward 70mm, so you’ll rebalance or stick to one focal length on a gimbal.
- Aperture control. The Sigma’s de-clickable aperture ring allows smooth, silent exposure changes during a take. The Tamron has no ring and no switches on the Sony version, so aperture, focus mode and stabilization settings all live in the camera body. Amateur Photographer’s review pointed this out too.
- Manual focus feel. Photography Blog found the Tamron’s focus ring light and not especially well damped. That matters if you pull focus by hand.
- Focus breathing. Sigma says breathing is suppressed, and reviewers agree it’s slight. Tamron also says it suppresses breathing, but I haven’t found a measured comparison, so I’d treat both as “fine” rather than ranking them.
For a run-and-gun shooter walking with the camera, the Tamron’s stabilization usually matters more than any of the above. For a seated interview, a short film or a gimbal setup, the Sigma’s design is the better fit.
Handling and build
Both are sealed against the weather to a degree. Sigma describes a dust- and splash-resistant structure with a water- and oil-repellent front element. Tamron uses moisture-resistant seals throughout the barrel. Neither is waterproof.
In the hand, the Sigma feels more like a cinema-style tool, with its aperture ring, AF/MF switch and two customisable AFL buttons. The Tamron is a plain point-and-shoot zoom by comparison: two rings and nothing to set on the barrel, which makes it easy to hand to someone else without explaining anything.
Who should buy which
Buy the Sigma 17-40mm F1.8 if:
- You shoot indoors, at night or at events and want low ISO without flash.
- You want prime-like subject separation in a zoom.
- Your body has IBIS, or you work on a gimbal or tripod.
- You already own a telephoto, or a short prime, for the longer shots.
Buy the Tamron 17-70mm F2.8 VC if:
- You want one lens for travel, family and day-to-day shooting.
- Your camera has no in-body stabilization and you shoot handheld video.
- You need 70mm for portraits, events or details across a room.
- You’d rather spend less and keep the change for a fast prime later.
Want even more range in one lens? My Sigma 16-300mm vs Tamron 18-300mm comparison covers the all-in-one superzooms. Or, if you’re set on the Sigma, see how it stacks up against the smaller Sigma 18-50mm F2.8 and Sony’s native 16-55mm F2.8 G.
Related reading
- Tamron 16-30mm f/2.8 G2 vs 17-28mm f/2.8
- Sigma 12mm f1.4 vs Viltrox 13mm f1.4: Which Wide-Angle Lens Is Better for Sony E Mount?
- Viltrox AF 50mm F2.0 Air vs Sony FE 50mm F1.8 – Which One’s the Better Everyday 50?
- Meike 85mm f/1.4 vs Samyang 85mm f/1.4 II: A Hands-On Comparison
FAQ
Is the Tamron 17-70mm lighter than the Sigma 17-40mm?
No. On Sony E-mount, both weigh 525 g according to their makers, and both take 67mm filters. The Tamron does get longer as you zoom.
Does the Tamron’s stabilization make up for its slower aperture?
For still subjects and handheld video, often yes. For moving subjects in low light, no. Stabilization can’t freeze motion, and that’s where the Sigma’s extra light helps.
Which is better for portraits?
The Sigma gives more blur at 40mm. The Tamron’s 70mm end (105mm equivalent) is a more flattering portrait length and narrows the gap. If you mostly shoot headshots, the Tamron is a strong choice.
Which works better on a gimbal?
The Sigma. Its internal zoom keeps the balance point fixed, and you can adjust the aperture ring without touching the camera.
Are there other mounts?
Yes. The Sigma is also made for L-Mount, Fujifilm X and Canon RF. The Tamron is available for Fujifilm X, and since 2026 also for Nikon Z and Canon RF.