Synology DS1522+ vs DS923+: NAS Storage Comparison
Are you looking for a top-notch NAS solution? The Synology DS1522+ and DS923+ are two great choices from the Plus series. They’re perfect for home users and small businesses. Let’s compare them to find the best fit for you.
The DS923+ is a four-bay powerhouse with 4GB of DDR4 ECC memory. The DS1522+ offers more bays for extra storage. Knowing these differences is key to making the right choice.
When comparing the DS1522+ vs DS923+, look at processing power, storage, and networking. The DS923+ has read/write speeds up to 592 MB/s and 562 MB/s. It also supports up to 10GbE networking, making it versatile.
In this article, we’ll dive into the features, performance, and value of these two Synology NAS models. Whether you need a media server or a reliable storage solution, this comparison will guide you. Find out which device meets your needs.
Key Features Overview
The Synology DS1522+ and DS923+ have amazing features. They use the AMD Ryzen R1600 dual-core processor. This processor runs at 2.6GHz but can go up to 3.1GHz when needed.
This powerful CPU makes sure both models work smoothly. They can handle many tasks without a hitch.
Processing Power and Architecture
Both models have the same processor, a change from Intel in the past. This switch means better performance and less energy use.
Memory Configuration
The DS1522+ starts with 8GB DDR4 ECC memory. The DS923+ begins with 4GB. But, both can go up to 32GB.
This extra memory is great for running many apps and handling big databases.
Storage Capabilities
The DS1522+ has five drive bays, expandable to 15 with DX517 units. The DS923+ starts with four bays, expandable to 9.
This means the DS1522+ can hold up to 330TB. The DS923+ can hold up to 198TB, using 22TB hard drives.
Both models have two M.2 NVMe SSD bays for faster caching. They support various drives, from HDDs to SSDs. This meets different storage needs and budgets.
Design and Build Quality Comparison
The Synology NAS design for both the DS1522+ and DS923+ looks sleek and professional. They have a sturdy plastic chassis with a matte black finish. This makes them perfect for both home and office use. The DS1522+ has five drive bays, while the DS923+ has four.
Both NAS devices are well-made, despite their size difference. They have tool-less, hot-swappable drive bays for easy setup and replacement. Synology has paid close attention to detail, ensuring good ventilation and port placement on both models.
Key design features include:
- Matte black finish for a professional look
- Tool-less, hot-swappable drive bays
- Excellent ventilation for optimal cooling
- Strategically placed ports for easy access
The DS1522+ is a bit larger because of its extra bay. Yet, both units are compact enough for different workspace setups. Their solid construction and user-friendly design make them great for demanding storage needs.
Hardware Architecture Differences
The Synology DS1522+ and DS923+ have similar hardware, but they differ in key areas. Both use the AMD Ryzen R1600 CPU, a change from Intel Celeron. This upgrade brings faster speeds but lacks integrated graphics, affecting tasks like video transcoding.
CPU Performance Analysis
The DS923+ has a dual-core AMD Ryzen R1600 CPU at 3.1GHz. This CPU is faster than its predecessors and uses less power, from 12W to 25W. The DS1522+ also uses this CPU, offering strong performance for many NAS tasks.
Memory Management Systems
Both models support ECC memory for data safety. The DS1522+ starts with 8GB RAM, and the DS923+ with 4GB. Both can be upgraded to 32GB, boosting performance in tasks that need lots of memory.
Cooling Solutions
Both the DS1522+ and DS923+ have effective cooling systems. They have many ventilation points and smart fan setups. This keeps temperatures stable, even when they’re working hard. Good cooling helps these NAS systems run smoothly and last longer.
Storage Expansion Capabilities
Synology NAS expansion options differ between the DS1522+ and DS923+. The DS1522+ can grow up to 15 drive bays, thanks to two DX517 expansion units. This means you can go from 5 to 15 bays, reaching a storage capacity of 330TB with 22TB drives. On the other hand, the DS923+ can add one DX517 unit, expanding from 4 to 9 bays with a max of 198TB.
The DS1522+ is great for businesses or users with big media collections. Both models use Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR) for better storage and protection. This makes them good for all kinds of businesses, from small startups to big companies.
The DS923+ may have less room to grow than the DS1522+, but it’s still a solid choice. It’s perfect for small to medium businesses or home users who need to expand but don’t need as much space. Adding drives as needed keeps both NAS options affordable for growing data.
- DS1522+: Up to 15 drive bays (5 built-in + 10 via expansion)
- DS923+: Up to 9 drive bays (4 built-in + 5 via expansion)
- Both support Synology Hybrid RAID for flexible storage management
When picking a Synology NAS, think about your future storage needs. The DS1522+ has more room for growth, while the DS923+ is better for those expecting moderate growth. Your decision will depend on your storage needs and budget.
Synology DS1522+ vs DS923+: Performance Comparison
The Synology DS1522+ and DS923+ have similar performance. They both use the AMD Ryzen R1600 processor, which can go up to 3.1GHz. This means they have similar speeds for most tasks.
Direct Performance Benchmarks
Tests show the DS1522+ and DS923+ perform almost the same. The DS1522+ might do better with many tasks because it has more memory. The DS923+ can handle up to 32GB RAM, but the DS1522+ can take more.
Real-world Usage Scenarios
Both devices are great for everyday tasks like file sharing and backups. The DS1522+ is better for handling lots of tasks at once because of its extra RAM. This makes it good for small businesses.
Price-to-Performance Ratio
The DS1522+ costs more but has more features. It has an extra drive bay and more memory. It’s a good choice for those who need more storage or run memory-heavy apps.
But, the DS923+ is a great deal for those who want good performance without spending too much. It’s perfect for home users and small businesses with simpler needs.
Network Connectivity Options
Synology NAS networking is key for top performance. The DS1522+ and DS923+ offer strong features for different business needs. They both have two 1GbE ports, great for home and small business use.
Default Network Ports
The DS1522+ and DS923+ have two 1GbE ports for fast speeds. These ports are good for file transfers, streaming, and backups. Most users find this setup meets their needs without needing more.
10GbE Upgrade Potential
You can add a 10GbE network upgrade module to both NAS models. This upgrade makes your network much faster. It’s perfect for businesses with big files or many users.
Link Aggregation Support
The DS1522+ and DS923+ support link aggregation. This lets you combine port bandwidths for better performance and protection. It’s a great way to boost your NAS network without the 10GbE upgrade.
When choosing between the DS1522+ and DS923+, think about your networking needs now and later. Both models let you grow your NAS setup as your data needs increase.
NVMe SSD Implementation
The Synology DS1522+ and DS923+ are top-notch for Synology NAS SSD caching. They each have two M.2 NVMe SSD slots. This boosts read and write speeds for data you use a lot. It’s great for tasks like database work or video editing.
The DS1522+ supports NVMe for caching. It starts with 8GB of ECC memory, but you can add up to 32GB. It doesn’t have an LCD for performance updates, but it has four LAN ports and can be upgraded to 10GbE. You can also add up to 10 more drives with two DS517 units.
The DS923+ SSD performance is even better. It uses NVMe SSDs for caching and as storage pools. This is a big plus for those needing super-fast storage. It supports up to 32GB of DDR4 memory and has an AMD R1600 CPU, a step up from the Intel Celeron in its predecessor.
Both models offer strong RAID setups. The DS1522+ supports Synology Hybrid RAID for mixed capacity setups. The DS923+ can be set up in RAID 5 with four 16TB HDDs, giving about 43.7TB of space. Users love the software, giving the DS923+ a perfect 10/10 score.
Power Consumption and Efficiency
When picking a NAS, it’s important to look at how much power it uses. The DS1522+ and DS923+ have different power needs. This can affect your costs over time, especially if you use it all day every day.
Idle State Power Usage
The DS923+ is great at using little power when it’s not doing much. It uses less than 0.5 W when it’s in standby mode. This meets the ErP Lot 6 2013 standards for low power use.
Even though we don’t have exact numbers for both models, their low standby power shows they’re good at saving energy.
Full Load Power Draw
When the NAS is working hard, it uses more power. The DS1522+ might use a bit more because it has more features. To know exactly how much, you’d need a tool like the GW Instek GPM-8213.
Energy Efficiency Features
Both NAS models probably have features to save energy:
- Drive hibernation during inactivity
- Efficient CPU power management
- ErP compliance for minimal standby power draw
These features help make the DS1522+ and DS923+ more efficient. They help lower power use and costs over time.
Business Applications and Use Cases
Synology NAS for business offers solutions for many needs. The DS1522+ and DS923+ are great for different business sizes. They provide strong storage and tools for work.
The DS1522+ is perfect for big businesses. It has 5 drive bays and up to 32GB RAM. This makes it great for handling lots of data or running many virtual machines. It also has up to 72TB storage, perfect for growing companies.
The DS923+ is ideal for small businesses. It has 4 drive bays and supports Synology Hybrid RAID. This gives a good mix of speed and storage options. It’s great for startups or remote offices needing solid data management.
Both NAS devices support Synology’s business apps:
- Synology Drive for easy file syncing and sharing
- Active Backup for full data protection
- Surveillance Station for managing IP cameras
These features make Synology NAS a key asset for businesses. Whether you need the DS1522+ for big businesses or the DS923+ for small ones, Synology has scalable solutions. They meet your data storage and management needs.
Media Server Capabilities
Synology NAS media servers are great for home entertainment fans. The DS1522+ and DS923+ are top choices for streaming media.
Plex Performance
The DS1522+ Plex performance is impressive, thanks to its AMD Ryzen processor. It handles many streams at once, perfect for big families. The DS923+ also does well, but it might not handle as many streams for top-quality content.
Transcoding Capabilities
The DS923+ is good at transcoding, but there’s a catch. It uses AMD processors without integrated graphics. This can slow down transcoding, especially for 4K files. If you often convert high-resolution files, look for other options or devices that can play content directly.
Multimedia Apps Support
Both NAS devices are great with multimedia apps. They work well with Plex, Synology Video Station, and Audio Station. This lets you build a media center that fits your needs.
To get the best performance, upgrade your network. A 10GbE Ethernet connection can really improve streaming quality, especially with SSDs. Keep in mind, these NAS servers might need RAM upgrades for heavy tasks. The DS1522+ starts with 8GB, and the DS923+ with 4GB, but can go up to 32GB.
Price Analysis and Value Proposition
Synology NAS pricing is key when deciding between the DS1522+ and DS923+. The DS1522+ is about $100-$120 more than the DS923+ at launch. This price difference shows the unique features and capabilities of each model.
The DS1522+ stands out for its extra drive bay, pre-installed memory, and support for two expansion units. It’s perfect for those needing lots of storage or planning for future upgrades. You can add up to 15 drives, greatly increasing your storage space.
The DS923+ offers great value for its lower price. It still has strong features like:
- 4 drive bays, expandable to 9 with an expansion unit
- 2 M.2 NVMe drive slots for better performance
- Optional 10GbE upgrade for faster network speeds
- 3-year hardware warranty, extendable to 5 years
Your choice depends on your needs and budget. Think about your current and future storage needs, the apps you’ll use, and how much you’ll grow. Both models are great investments for different users.
Future-Proofing and Upgrade Paths
The DS1522+ and DS923+ are great for future upgrades. The DS923+ can have up to 32GB of memory, a big jump from the 8GB of older models. This means your NAS can grow with your needs over time.
Both models are fast, thanks to their 10GbE upgrade potential. The DS923+ has a PCIe Gen 3 x2 slot for speeds up to 1,000 MB/s. This is ten times faster than regular gigabit connections. It’s perfect for users who need faster data transfers in the future.
The DS1522+ leads in storage growth. While the DS923+ can expand to 9 drives with one unit, the DS1522+ can add two DX517 units. This allows for up to 15 drives total. It’s great for users who expect to need more storage soon.
Both models run DSM 7.1, Synology’s latest operating system. DSM 7.2 is coming soon. This means your NAS will always be up-to-date with the latest features and security, no matter which model you pick.
